Menu of Fellinis Pizzeria Penn Hills in Penn Ridge, Penn Hills Township, PA, USA

Menu Overview

Fellinis Pizzeria Penn Hills stands as a hidden gem along Frankstown Road, offering an appetizing slice of comfort food that punches well above its modest exterior. This pizza joint isn’t merely about tossing dough and sauce—it’s about crafting satisfying meals that echo the familiar flavors of classic New York-style pies while adding their own local flair.

At the heart of the menu are the pizzas, which range from the straightforward Personal Cheese Pizza to the richly topped Cheeseburger Pizza. The thin crust forms a flaky, almost crisp base that balances the savory sauce and melty cheese beautifully. The Pepperoni Pizza, a perennial favorite, delivers that perfect marriage of spice and grease—appealing to those who appreciate a bit of oiliness as Jonathan Zora aptly notes. For those looking to share or feed a crowd, the deal on two large 16-inch cheese pizzas at $38.99 represents solid value, embodying the generosity one expects from a neighborhood pizzeria.

Beyond pies, Fellinis shines with its sandwich and sub offerings. Their 6-inch subs provide a hearty alternative to pizza without straying far from comfort food territory. The Half Pound Burger with Small Fries is another must-try highlight, boasting a juicy well-charred patty and crispy bacon, earning praise from those like Kimberly Porter who appreciate a well-executed burger alongside their pizza.

The Fellini Bites deserve special mention—they are bite-sized, flavorful side snacks perfect for sharing or snacking on the go. The Spinach Mushroom Bites with Ranch stand out with a fresh earthiness cutoff by creamy ranch, while other variants like Garlic & Cheese, Bacon Cheddar, and Pepperoni Bites complement the main courses with bursts of seasoning and indulgence.

Sauce selections here add an extra layer of customization, all priced affordably at $1.50. From classic Ranch and BBQ Sauce to the uniquely enticing Mike’s Hot Honey and Nacho Cheese, the condiments enhance the dish experience without overpowering the main ingredients. The inclusion of a complimentary fork, knife, and napkin set shows thoughtful attention to the takeout-only model, signaling convenience without compromising on presentation.

The overall customer sentiment underscores consistent food quality, highlighted by Joshua Smith’s approval of the balance between sauce, cheese, and toppings, and B M’s praise for friendly delivery service. While counter service might lack warmth, the food’s reliability keeps patrons coming back, making it a viable lunch spot for locals working in Penn Hills. Some criticism, such as Robert Fox’s experience with boneless wings, suggests sticking to the core pizza and bites offerings for the best experience.

Fellinis Pizzeria Penn Hills strikes a commendable balance between value, variety, and quality, making it a strong contender amid local pizza chains. Its menu caters to diverse cravings—from cheesy pies and burgers to shareable bites—all infused with a down-to-earth charm that invites you back time and time again.